SEX ED AND THE MAGICAL UTERUS

March 8, 2011 3 Comments by Duchess Harris

This blog entry is in honor of International Women’s Day.

I am a progressive parent, and two of our three children go to Montessori School. When I went to our daughter’s first grade parent/teacher conference and found out that they were going to be learning about reproductive health, I took it in stride. We were given a copy of How You Were Born by Joanna Cole, who is most famous as the author of The Magic School Bus.

They gave us two weeks to read the book with our child, and then the girls would discuss it at school with the female first grade teacher, and the boys would discuss it with the male first grade teacher. This all seemed reasonable.

When I picked up the book, which Parent’s Magazine dubs, “The best book we’ve seen yet on the subject,” I was slightly confused. I wouldn’t consider myself an expert, but I started figuring out where babies came from when I was still wearing Garanimals.

Now if you factor out assisted reproductive technology, there is a penis somewhere in the conception story.

So I decided that I must have missed the penis in the 48-page book. But on a second and then third reading, I never spotted the organ that I was glad to meet somewhere between the Garanimals stage of life, and the push-up bra phase.

I did some research. According to School Library Journal, the original version of the book came out in 1984. By 1993, “the diagrams of the male and female reproductive systems are left out.”

Yes, those minor, unimportant details.

I have moved from confusion to concern. In 2011 we are sophisticated enough to read this with our child,

“You went from the uterus into the vagina, a special tunnel that connects the uterus to the outside. The vagina can stretch wide to let a baby pass through. First your head appeared. Then your whole body came out;” (p 34)

But the only explanation for how the baby got there is,

“In a man’s body are sperm cells. The sperm cells have long tails and can swim. When a sperm and an egg join together, they form a special cell that can grow into a baby.” (19)

Now when my kids ask where the heck the sperm cells are, where is the illustration for that? Why are we comfortable labeling the uterus and vagina, but not the penis? In 2011 women’s bodies are for display, and men’s bodies aren’t?

Joanna Cole leaves the child confused thinking that women are solely responsible for childbirth, and this message isn’t helpful in a political climate that wants to control women’s bodies.

Their effort to control women’s bodies makes sense to me now. We have The Magical Uterus.

3 Comments

  1. Chris Molanphy
    351 days ago

    Thank you for taking something obnoxious and making it so hilarious I nearly spit out my tea at 8 in the morning.

    When I was a kid, I'd been told that the egg was fertilized by sperm from the father, and because the sex part was left out (blame my über-Catholic parents and their easy embarrassment — but that's a story for another day), I thought this was some kind of medical procedure. I figured at some point my parents had gone to a doctors office together, and a tube was connected to my Dad for collection of the magical sperm. So even in the more sex-positive '70s, some very important details were, shall we say, elided.

  2. Anonymous
    351 days ago

    I agree with Chris, this is funny! It brought back bad memories of sitting on the livingroom floor with my mom looking at the medical encyclopedia while she pointed out this the male this is the felmale and on and on

    …..Maria

  3. Camilla Engblom
    239 days ago

    Dear Professor Harris,

    when I read this, I thought of a video clip I had seen recently:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ry-LwxR746s

    She has some suggestions on how to talk about where the sperm and the egg meet. :)

    Hope all is well,

    Best

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.